The night was unusually quiet in the Arconia.
At least, it had been until the elevator chimed. A single ding echoed down the art-deco hallways, signaling another chapter in a saga that refuses to rest in peace. As if on cue, the shadows returned—full of whispered secrets, musical theater tangents, and one dead doorman. Yes, murder is back. And so are they.
Charles, Oliver, and Mabel have never been more fractured, more famous, or more hunted. But when tragedy strikes too close to home, the trio must once again untangle a web of lies that spans luxury penthouses, Broadway stages, and criminal underworlds. Just when you thought the mystery was over, Season 5 begins like a bullet ricocheting off a chandelier.
When Is Only Murders in the Building Season 5 Coming Out?
Mark your calendar: The Only Murders in the Building Season 5 release date is Tuesday, September 9, 2025.
The first three episodes will drop on premiere day, with the rest airing weekly. The show returns to Hulu, the official U.S. distributor, and will stream internationally on Disney+, including JioCinema/Hotstar in India.
This staggered global rollout reflects Disney’s expanded international strategy, with the series becoming a cornerstone for Disney-owned platforms across regions. Hulu and Disney+ have both heavily promoted the return, with teaser posters already making waves online.
Back From the Dead: What We Know So Far
Season 5 picks up with the sudden, suspicious death of Lester, the beloved Arconia doorman. It’s not just a tragedy; it’s personal. And the implications run deeper than anyone expected. Is the Arconia cursed? Or are its residents just exceptionally unlucky?
Meanwhile, Oliver (Martin Short) is struggling to keep his Broadway revival alive, while Charles (Steve Martin) battles memory lapses that may not be so innocent. And Mabel (Selena Gomez)? She’s trying to rebuild a life away from the Arconia—but murder always finds its way back.
Rumors have swirled since Season 4 ended about a “legacy killer” targeting those connected to the building. Some fans believe Lester’s death ties back to Jan Bellows (Amy Ryan), last seen ominously sketching a portrait behind bars.
Who’s In, Who’s Out: Cast Surprises & Controversies
Returning are our favorite trio: Steve Martin, Martin Short, and Selena Gomez, each facing their own character arcs and growing tensions.
But Season 5’s cast shakeup is turning heads. Among the newest additions:
- Renée Zellweger, playing a cold-blooded Broadway producer with a vendetta.
- Christoph Waltz, rumored to be a mafia-tied art dealer with secrets in the Arconia’s basement.
- Logan Lerman, cast as a Gen Z true-crime podcaster trying to “out-investigate” the original trio.
- Dianne Wiest as an opera singer with a suspicious past and a voice that could kill (literally?).
Oh, and Meryl Streep is back—but in what capacity? “She’s not who you think she is,” teased showrunner John Hoffman in an interview. Speculation suggests she might be connected to Lester’s past or even orchestrating the chaos herself.
Behind the scenes, filming was delayed in early 2025 due to a brief production halt when Short contracted laryngitis. Thankfully, the delay was minimal, and shooting wrapped just weeks later.
Watch the Official Season 5 Trailer
Get a glimpse of what’s to come: broken friendships, locked doors, cryptic piano tunes, and… a puppet show?
Whispers from the Arconia: Fan Buzz & Theories
Online communities have once again gone into full detective mode.
At this point, that building needs to be renamed “Mostly Murders.” 🕵️♂️🔪
— daily cinema (@movies_vault) July 23, 2025
happy to see them again! pic.twitter.com/iNm6hHYjUl
— ⭑ (@estrellithee) July 24, 2025
FAQ: Burning Questions About Only Murders in the Building Season 5
Is Season 5 the final season?
No official word yet, but showrunner hints suggest it might be the end of the road.
Will Jan Bellows return?
Teasers and leaked photos strongly suggest yes—and she’s still obsessed with Charles.
Are there any crossovers or cameos?
Whispers say a certain NYC-based Marvel character could pop in (yes, seriously).
Where was Season 5 filmed?
Mostly in New York, with key scenes at a historic opera house and a “mystery estate” upstate.
Final Thoughts: The Last Note or Just Another Prelude?
If there’s one thing Only Murders in the Building has taught us, it’s this: never trust the final bow.
Season 5 is shaping up to be more than just a continuation. It feels like a crescendo. From the new high-profile cast members to increasingly layered plotlines and meta-commentary on fame, storytelling, and obsession, this could be the most emotional season yet.
Whether or not this is the end, the stakes have never been higher. With echoes of Season 1 and callbacks laced into every teaser, it’s clear the writers are playing the long game.
So, do you think Lester’s murder was just the beginning… or the final curtain?
Do you think Lester’s murder was just the beginning… or the final curtain? Drop your theories below!
